Mackinac Island, a summer wonderland located in Lake Huron, Michigan, offers a unique blend of natural beauty and rich culinary heritage.
The island’s dining scene is influenced by local traditions and fresh ingredients, offering a variety of choices for food lovers.
Let’s explore 10 best restaurants on Mackinac Island together!
Table of Contents
1. Pink Pony
Address: 7221 Main St #103, Mackinac Island, MI 49757, United States
Cuisine: American
Business Hours: 11:00 am to 2:00 am daily
Ambiance: Fun and Casual
Reservations: Recommended, call +1 906-847-3341
Serving contemporary American cuisine, the Pink Pony offers a diverse menu, including gluten-free and vegetarian options.
Known for its famous Whitefish Dip and Rum Runner cocktails, this dining spot caters to breakfast, lunch, and dinner.
The restaurant boasts a lively ambiance with an eclectic décor, showcasing its signature pink hues and marine-inspired motifs.
The outdoor patio offers panoramic views of the marina, perfect for a relaxing meal.
Stand-Out Dish: Try the Pink Pony Burger, a juicy Angus beef patty with special pink sauce, lettuce, and tomato, all served on a brioche bun.
2. The Gate House
Address: 7127 Huron Rd, Mackinac Island, MI 49757
Cuisine: American & European
Business Hours: 11:00 am to 10:00 pm daily
Ambiance: Upscale and Elegant
Reservations: Accepted, call +1 906-847-3772
Offering casual dining with Mediterranean-inspired flavors, The Gate House boasts a wide selection of appetizers, salads, sandwiches, and entrees.
The restaurant features a full bar with an extensive wine list, craft beer offerings, and cocktail options.
The casual yet sophisticated setting, adorned with vintage photos and elegant fabric, is suitable for both intimate and group gatherings.
Stand-Out Dish: Enjoy the signature Pecan-Crusted Whitefish, a delicious blend of buttery pecan crust and tender fish fillet, accompanied by herb-roasted potatoes and fresh vegetables.
3. Mary’s Bistro Draught House
Address: 7463 Main St, Mackinac Island, MI 49757, United States
Cuisine: Contemporary American & Bar Fare
Business Hours: 11:00 am to 11:00 pm daily
Ambiance: Lively & Relaxed
Reservations: Accepted, call +1 906-847-9911
Specializing in locally sourced ingredients, Mary’s Bistro Draught House serves up an array of comfort food with a modern twist.
With several vegetarian and gluten-free options available, the restaurant offers a diverse dining experience for lunch and dinner.
The casual and friendly atmosphere, combined with the rustic yet modern décor, provides a welcoming and relaxing dining environment.
Mary’s Bistro Draught House also features a full bar with 50 different craft brews on tap.
Stand-Out Dish: Savor the famous Drunken Noodles, a delightful combination of stir-fried
4. Millie’s on Main
Address: 7294 Main St, Mackinac Island, MI 49757, United States
Cuisine: American
Business Hours: 8:00 am to 8:00 pm daily
Ambiance: Quaint & Charming
Reservations: Recommended, call +1 906-847-9901
Millie’s on Main is a cozy cafe serving classic American dishes with local ingredients.
From breakfast plates to dinner entrees, the menu offers something for everyone and features seasonal specials.
The interior of Millie’s is decorated with rustic touches and has an inviting atmosphere that caters to both families and couples alike.
Whether you’re looking for a quick bite or a relaxing evening meal, Millie’s on Main will not disappoint.
Stand-Out Dish: The Lakeshore Skillet is a must-try, which consists of potatoes, onions, peppers, and your choice of bacon or sausage all cooked together in one skillet.
5. Yankee Rebel Tavern
Address: 1493 Astor St, Mackinac Island, MI 49757, United States
Cuisine: American Bar Food
Business Hours: 11:00 am to 11:00 pm daily
Ambiance: Friendly & Casual
Reservations: Not accepted, call +1 906-847-6249
The Yankee Rebel Tavern is a popular spot on Mackinac Island for casual dining and drinks.
The menu features classic bar food favorites like burgers, wings, fries, and salads as well as specialty dishes such as the famous mac-and-cheese balls and the bacon-wrapped jalapeno poppers.
Not only does the tavern offer an extensive selection of beer and spirits but also a wide variety of wines by the glass or bottle.
The inviting atmosphere of this establishment makes it a great place to enjoy relaxed conversations with friends over a meal or drink.
Stand-Out Dish: Try the Black & Blue Burger – an Angus beef patty topped with fresh blue cheese crumbles, bacon bits, and creamy garlic sauce – served on a brioche bun.
6. Bistro On The Greens
Address: One Lake Shore Dr, Mackinac Island, MI 49757, United States
Cuisine: American & European Fusion
Business Hours: 11:00 am to 9:00 pm daily
Ambiance: Casual & Relaxed
Reservations: Recommended, call +1 906-847-3000
Bistro On The Greens is the perfect spot for casual dining with a menu that features flavors from both American and European cuisines.
The restaurant specializes in preparing fresh seafood and steak dishes with seasonal ingredients sourced locally whenever possible.
A wide selection of wines and craft beer is also available to complement any meal.
Enjoy the relaxed atmosphere with vintage décor and beautiful views of the golf course as you savor flavorful dishes expertly prepared by their chefs.
Stand-Out Dish: Try the Bistro’s signature Crab Cake Sandwich – two freshly made jumbo lump crab cakes served on a grilled brioche bun with lettuce, tomato, onion, and an herb mayonnaise sauce.
7. 1852 Grill Room
Address: Inside Island House Hotel, 6966 Main St, Mackinac Island, MI 49757, United States
Cuisine: American Steakhouse & Seafood
Business Hours: 4:00 pm to 9:00 pm daily
Ambiance: Upscale & Sophisticated
Reservations: Accepted, call +1 906-847-7222
The 1852 Grill Room is a contemporary steakhouse that serves up classic American cuisine with an emphasis on fresh seafood and steaks.
The menu features a selection of shareable dishes and entrees that are prepared from scratch using locally sourced ingredients whenever possible.
The chic yet inviting atmosphere features leather booths, dark wood accents, and plush carpets as well as modern artworks that give the room an upscale feel.
The restaurant also boasts an extensive collection of wines and handcrafted cocktails to complement any meal.
Stand-Out Dish: Try the Grilled New York Strip Steak – 12 oz of premium USDA prime beef cooked to perfection and served with your choice of side and fresh vegetable garnish.
8. Woods Restaurants
Address: 8655 Cudahy Cir, Mackinac Island, MI 49757, United States
Cuisine: Italian & Mediterranean Fusion
Business Hours: 5:00 pm to 10:00 pm daily
Ambiance: Intimate & Cozy
Reservations: Recommended, call +1 906-847-3699
Woods Restaurants is a family-owned restaurant offering authentic Italian dishes fused with flavors from the Mediterranean region.
Featuring a cozy atmosphere with rustic decor elements such as reclaimed wood furniture and vintage picturesque paintings adorning the wall, this dining spot provides a relaxing environment suitable for enjoying romantic dinners for two or group gatherings alike.
The menu includes an array of antipasti plates, artisanal pizzas, homemade pasta, and much more – all made using only fresh seasonal ingredients sourced locally when possible.
Stand-Out Dish: Indulge in the Braised Lamb Shank – fork-tender lamb shank slow-cooked in garlic demi-glace sauce until it falls off the bone – served over creamy mashed potatoes with sautéed vegetables for extra flavor.
9. Seabiscuit Cafe
Address: 7337 Main St, Mackinac Island, MI 49757, United States
Cuisine: American Comfort Food
Business Hours: 8:00 am to 9:00 pm daily
Ambiance: Casual & Relaxing
Reservations: Not accepted
Seabiscuit Cafe is a local favorite serving up classic homestyle comfort food with modern touches.
The menu features all the classic dishes such as burgers and fries as well as specialty items like the popular Biscuit Pot Pie and seasonal specials.
All ingredients are sourced locally whenever possible to ensure freshness and flavor in every bite.
The inviting atmosphere of this establishment makes it an ideal spot for families or couples looking for a laid-back meal in a casual setting.
Enjoy your meal while surrounded by vintage artwork adorning the walls and rustic wood furniture that add extra charm to the decor.
Stand-Out Dish: Give the Chicken ‘n Waffle Sliders a try – tender fried chicken placed between two mini waffles with candy bacon pieces and topped with maple syrup for extra sweetness – served with honey cream butter.
10. Round Island Kitchen
Address: One Lake Shore Dr, Mackinac Island, MI 49757, United States
Cuisine: Eclectic American Cuisine
Business Hours: 4:00 pm to 11:00 pm daily
Ambiance: Trendy & Exciting
Reservations: Recommended, call +1 906-847-3000
Round Island Kitchen offers an eclectic selection of flavors from around America in one menu featuring traditional dishes as well as creating new takes on classic favorites.
Enjoy upscale bistro-style meals prepared using only high-quality ingredients sourced locally when possible.
With dimly lit interiors that feature industrial decor elements such as exposed brick walls and metal accents, this restaurant provides an exciting atmosphere suitable for date nights out or group gatherings alike.
A wide selection of craft beer and signature cocktails are also available to complete any meal.
Stand-Out Dish: Try their rendition of Chicken & Waffles – crisp buttermilk fried chicken with a Belgian waffle topped with cranberry chutney, candied walnuts, and honey butter glaze – served with maple syrup for extra sweetness.
Read Also
- 10 Best Restaurants in Curacao (2023)
- 10 Best Restaurants in Anguilla (2023)
- 10 Best Restaurants in the Woodlands (2023)
- 10 Best Restaurants in St Barths (2023)
- 10 Best Restaurants in Cozumel (2023)
- 10 Best Restaurants in Alpharetta (2023)
- 10 Best Restaurants in Galveston (2023)
- 10 Best Restaurants in Waikiki (2023)
- 10 Best Restaurants in Bar Harbor (2023)
- 10 Best Restaurants in Lima (2023)
Frequently Asked Questions
What ingredients does Round Island Kitchen use?
Round Island Kitchen uses only high-quality ingredients sourced locally when possible. They specialize in preparing traditional dishes as well as creating new takes on classic favorites. The menu features flavors from all around America, making it an ideal spot for sampling traditional dishes with a modern twist.
What time is the kitchen open at Round Island Kitchen?
Round Island Kitchen is open from 4:00 pm to 11:00 pm daily.
Is there a dress code for the 1852 Grill Room?
Yes, the 1852 Grill Room has a dress code that requires guests to wear casual but appropriate attire. This usually means no shorts or sandals – collared shirts are preferred for men and dresses or skirts for women. The restaurant also reserves the right to deny entry if a guest is deemed inappropriately dressed.
Does Woods Restaurant accept reservations?
Yes, Woods Restaurant does accept reservations. You can call (906) 847-6366 or visit their website at www.woodsrestaurantsmackinac.com to make a reservation.
Are there vegan options at Seabiscuit Café?
Yes, Seabiscuit Café does have vegan options on its menu. They offer a variety of salads and sides that can be made vegan upon request as well as vegan-friendly Baked Mac & Cheese. Be sure to ask your server for more details.
Are there craft beers available at 1852 Grill Room?
Yes, the 1852 Grill Room offers a selection of craft beers to complement its menu. Some of the available rotations include selections from Bell’s Brewery, Founder’s Brewing Co., and more. Be sure to ask your server for more details.
Do all restaurants on Mackinac Island source local ingredients when possible?
Yes, all the restaurants on Mackinac Island source local ingredients when possible. They specialize in preparing traditional dishes as well as creating new takes on classic favorites using only high-quality fresh ingredients. This ensures great flavor and quality in every dish served.
What kind of atmosphere can I expect from Woods Restaurant?
Woods Restaurant offers a relaxed atmosphere and cozy ambiance. The interior features rustic decor elements such as vintage furniture, reclaimed wood pieces, natural stone accents, and artwork adorning the walls. Guests can enjoy their meals in an intimate setting suitable for romantic dinners or family gatherings alike. The restaurant also has an outdoor seating area where guests can take in the views of Mackinac Island while savoring their meals.
How would you describe the decor of Seabiscuit Cafe?
Seabiscuit Cafe’s decor features vintage artwork adorning the walls and rustic wood furniture that adds extra charm to the space. It has a casual and relaxing atmosphere, making it an ideal spot for families or couples looking for a laid-back meal in a casual setting.
What is the signature dish served at 1852 Grillroom?
The signature dish served at 1852 Grillroom is the Prime New York Strip Steak. This 14-ounce steak is cooked to perfection and topped with a flavorful herb butter, making for an unforgettable experience. The steak is served with a side of your choice, such as garlic mashed potatoes or French fries. It’s sure to be a crowd-pleaser among steak lovers!