Marco Island, situated off the coast of southwest Florida, is not just a picturesque destination known for its pristine beaches and recreational activities.
It also boasts an array of culinary delights that cater to every palate.
Whether you are a seafood lover or prefer indulging in juicy steaks, Marco Island is a special place.
Here is a compilation of the ten best restaurants in Marco Island that promise to take you on a delightful gastronomic journey.
Table of Contents
1. CJ’s on the Bay
Address: 740 N Collier Blvd Unit 105, Marco Island, FL 34145, United States
Working Hours: 11:30 am – 9 pm (Monday to Thursday), 11:30 am – 10 pm (Friday & Saturday)
Cuisine: American, Seafood
Ambiance: Casual waterfront dining
Reservations: Recommended
Specials: Happy Hour specials from 4 pm -7 pm.
Payment Options: Credit cards accepted
Nestled on the picturesque bayfront, CJ’s on the Bay offers breathtaking views with its alfresco seating. This restaurant specializes in delectable seafood dishes prepared with locally sourced ingredients. From succulent shrimp scampi to mouthwatering lobster bisque, their menu showcases flavors that will impress even discerning palates.
2. Marco Prime Steak & Seafood Restaurant
Address: 599 S Collier Blvd, Marco Island, FL 34145, United States
Working Hours: 4 pm -10 pm (daily)
Cuisine: Steakhouse, Seafood
Ambiance: Elegant steakhouse setting with modern décor
Reservations: Recommended
Specials: The Early Dining menu offers specially curated three-course meals at attractive prices.
Payment Options: Cash and credit cards accepted
Combining prime cuts of beef with fresh ocean treasures, Marco Prime Steak & Seafood Restaurant is a carnivore’s paradise. This chic establishment prides itself on serving tender steaks cooked to perfection and exquisite surf n’ turf creations that will make your taste buds dance in delight.
3. La Tavola Restaurant and Bar
Address: 961 Winterberry Dr, Marco Island, FL 34145, United States
Working Hours: 5 pm -9 pm (daily)
Cuisine: Italian
Ambiance: Cozy, intimate atmosphere with warm décor
Reservations: Recommended
Specials: Enjoy live music on select evenings.
Payment Options: Cash and credit cards accepted
Transport yourself to Italy at La Tavola Restaurant and Bar. This culinary gem captures the essence of traditional Italian cuisine, serving homemade pasta, delicate risottos, and luscious tiramisu. Each bite exudes authentic flavors that will transport you straight to the charming streets of Florence.
4. Sale e Pepe
Address: 480 S Collier Blvd, Marco Island, FL 34145, United States
Working Hours: 5 pm -10 pm (daily)
Cuisine: Italian, Mediterranean
Ambiance: Sophisticated waterfront dining
Reservations: Recommended
Specials: The extraordinary Chef’s Tasting Menu offers a six-course delight for those seeking an elevated culinary experience.
Payment Options: Cash and credit cards accepted
Sale e Pepe takes diners on an unforgettable gastronomic journey celebrating the vibrant cuisines of Italy and the Mediterranean. With its panoramic views of the Gulf waters, it provides a romantic backdrop for savoring dishes like handmade ravioli filled with flavorful ingredients or their famous branzino delicately prepared by skilled chefs.
5. The SpeakEasy Marco Island
Address: 1106 N Collier Blvd, Marco Island, FL 34145, United States
Working Hours: Cocktail lounge open from 6 pm until late (Tuesdays-Saturdays)
Cuisine: Bespoke cocktails & gourmet bar bites
Ambiance: ’20s-inspired secret speakeasy’; secret access details provided upon reservations
Reservations: Mandatory as per stated dress code policy; limited availability
Specials: A rotating menu showcasing imaginative cocktails curated by expert mixologists
Payment Options: Cash preferred; some credit cards may be accepted upon verification
Stepping into The SpeakEasy Marco Island is like entering a bygone era of glamour and intrigue. Nestled in a secret location, this covert establishment offers bespoke craft cocktails that will transport you to the intoxicating days of the Roaring Twenties. With each sip, you’ll experience extraordinary concoctions crafted with precision and flair.
6. Arturo’s Bistro
Address: 918 N Collier Blvd, Marco Island, FL 34145, United States
Working Hours: 5 pm -10 pm (daily)
Cuisine: Mediterranean, Spanish
Ambiance: Sophisticated yet intimate dining setting
Reservations: Recommended
Specials: A vast selection of tapas plates to share and savor divine flavors
Payment Options: Cash and credit cards accepted
Arturo’s Bistro transports you across the Mediterranean with its tantalizing menu inspired by Spain’s culinary heritage. Exquisite tapas plates showcase an array of flavors, from savory Iberian ham croquettes to delectable patatas bravas, guaranteed to leave your taste buds yearning for more.
7. The Oyster Society
Address: 599 S Collier Blvd #218, Marco Island, FL 34145, United States
Working Hours:5 pm -10 pm (Monday-Saturday), Closed on Sundays
Cuisine: Seafood
Ambiance: Elegantly casual seafood restaurant
Reservations: Recommended
Specials: The Happy Hour deals are not to be missed.
Payment Options: Cash and credit cards accepted
For seafood enthusiasts seeking ultimate freshness coupled with exquisite preparations, look no further than The Oyster Society. This upscale eatery offers an extensive selection of oysters along with a variety of delectable dishes showcasing the bounty of the sea in innovative ways.
8. Mango’s Dockside Bistro
Address: 760 N Collier Blvd # 109, Marco Island, FL 34145, United States
Working Hours: Lunch 11 am -3 pm; Dinner 4 pm -9 pm (daily)
Cuisine: Bistro-style American
Ambiance: Lively waterfront bistro
Reservations: Walk-ins welcome
Specials: The daily happy hour offers enticing drink specials.
Payment Options: Cash and credit cards accepted
Mango’s Dockside Bistro beckons diners to indulge in a delightful blend of American bistro-style dishes and coastal flair. With stunning waterfront vistas, this lively establishment offers a menu featuring fresh catch seafood, savory sandwiches, and delectable salads.
9. Fin Bistro
Address: 657 S Collier Blvd, Marco Island, FL 34145, United States
Working Hours:Lunch: 11 am -3 pm (Monday to Saturday); Dinner: 5 pm -9 pm (Monday-Saturday)
Cuisine: Seafood, New American
Ambiance: Casual chic
Reservations: Recommended
Specials: The multi-course Chef Tasting Menu guarantees an exceptional dining experience.
Payment Options: Cash and credit cards accepted
Combining fresh local ingredients with culinary creativity, Fin Bistro showcases the best of new American cuisine fused with tantalizing seafood offerings. Here you can discover delightful flavor combinations thoughtfully crafted by talented chefs, making each dish a gastronomic masterpiece.
10. Da Vinci Ristorante Italiano
Address: 599 S Collier Blvd, Marco Island, FL 34145, United States
Working Hours: Dinner from 4 pm (daily)
Cuisine: Italian
Ambiance: Intimate and inviting setting
Reservations: Mandatory; exclusive seating capacity
Specials: The homemade pasta is not to be missed for an authentic Italian experience.
Payment Options: Cash preferred; some credit cards may be accepted upon verification
Da Vinci Ristorante Italiano transports guests from Marco Island to the picturesque landscapes of Tuscany. Indulge in traditional Italian fare served with passion and precision by skilled artisans who pay homage to age-old recipes passed down through generations.
Read Also
- 10 Best Restaurants in Tempe (2023)
- 10 Best Restaurants in Times Square (2023)
- 10 Best Restaurants in Buffalo (2023)
- 10 Best Restaurants in Aspen (2023)
- 10 Best Restaurants in Arlington VA (2023)
- 10 Best Restaurants in Fort Collins (2023)
- 10 Best Restaurants in Spokane (2023)
- 10 Best Restaurants in Portsmouth NH (2023)
- 10 Best Restaurants in San Antonio Riverwalk (2023)
- 10 Best Restaurants in Columbia SC (2023)
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the popular attractions on Marco Island?
Some of the popular attractions on Marco Island include Tigertail Beach, Cape Romano, Marco Island Historical Museum, and the beautiful Keewaydin Island.
Are there any kid-friendly restaurants on Marco Island?
Yes, several kid-friendly restaurants on Marco Island cater to young diners with their menu options and family-friendly ambiance. Some of them include Mango’s Dockside Bistro and CJ’s on the Bay.
Can you recommend a restaurant with vegetarian or vegan options?
Certainly! La Tavola Restaurant and Bar offer a variety of vegetarian dishes made with fresh ingredients sourced locally. They also have vegan options available upon request.
Are there any seafood buffets available on Marco Island?
Yes, if you’re looking for a seafood buffet experience, The Oyster Society is an excellent choice. They offer a delectable array of fresh seafood dishes that will satisfy your cravings.
Which restaurant offers fine dining experiences with ocean views?
Sale e Pepe is renowned for its upscale atmosphere and breathtaking ocean views. It provides an ideal setting to enjoy fine dining while taking in the stunning scenery.
Can I make reservations at these restaurants in advance?
Yes, many of these establishments accept reservations in advance to ensure you secure your desired dining time and avoid disappointment during peak hours or seasons.
Are there any happy hour deals offered by these restaurants?
Several restaurants mentioned in our list have happy hour specials or drink deals during specific hours; CJ’s on the Bay and Mango’s Dockside Bistro are two examples where you can enjoy discounted beverages along with delicious food offerings during their designated happy hours.
Do any of these restaurants accommodate large groups or private events?
Certainly! Some of these establishments offer private event spaces or can accommodate larger groups upon request while providing personalized menus tailored to your needs; it is advisable to contact them directly for specific inquiries.
Can you recommend a romantic restaurant for a special occasion?
For a special romantic evening, Marco Prime Steak & Seafood Restaurant is an excellent choice. Its elegant setting, quality cuisine, and attentive service make it ideal for memorable celebrations.
What are the most popular desserts available at these restaurants?
Many of these restaurants offer mouthwatering desserts to satisfy your sweet tooth. Some favorites include tiramisu at La Tavola Restaurant and Bar, homemade gelato at Sale e Pepe, and delectable chocolate creations often found on the dessert menus of several establishments mentioned above.